Menu

Welcome!

Sonic Fan Games HQ is the largest resource for Sonic the Hedgehog fan gaming on the web and home to SAGE, the annual Sonic Amatuer Games Expo! We specialize in engines, sprites, music, gameplay, levels, gimmicks, the whole eight yards! Got a project you want to show off? Need some help with your game? Or maybe you just want to connect with creators and fans alike! No matter why you're here, hit that register button below to join the fun and start creating today!

  1. Hey Guest!

    We just updated our SFGHQ Rules & Guidelines. Give them a read, it might just save your life!

    Dismiss Notice
  2. Hey Guest!

    Our pals from the SHC are going to be running the Sonic Hacking Contest a little later this year, a bit after SAGE! You should totally check it out by clicking here!

    Dismiss Notice

The Perfect Music Style For Sonic?

Discussion in 'General Discussion' started by Clouder, Aug 29, 2017.

  1. Clouder

    Clouder The one and only

    • Messages: 49
    • Likes Received: 25
    Exactly what it says on the tin. What do you guys think is the perfect type of music for Sonic?

    In my opinion, it's a tie between the New Jack Swing-inspired tunes of Sonic 3, and the catchy, laid-back rock melodies in Sonic Adventure 1.





     
  2. Baron Von Jiggly

    Baron Von Jiggly Apple Wizard of Mt.Fuji

    • Messages: 22
    • Likes Received: 6
    i don't think there needs to be a specific music style for Sonic to be honest. I feel like whatever fits the game is good enough as long as the music itself is good.
     
  3. Atomikku

    Atomikku OfirToeiSonicFan

    • Messages: 19
    • Likes Received: 2
    Actually, I think Sonic CD-styled music fits Sonic the best. Also OVA's music because the style is very reminiscent of it.
    For main themes, I'd prefer Crush 40 to sing or even perform
     
  4. dante

    dante E Rank Member

    • Messages: 2
    • Likes Received: 5
    In terms of classic sonic, pretty much the only definitive answer to the question would be with Sonic CD's kind of stuff.

    However in terms of more modern, post-2000s sonic music I really don't see this thrown around often. When I think of a kind of music style that fits the modern idea of sonic the hedgehog, I usually think of the kind of sample-heavy breakbeat music that naganuma brought to the table in Sonic Rush, which was then essentially revitalized to be more in line with the sonic series by ohtani and nanba in Sonic Rush Adventure. These kinds of tracks really capture the quick, fast-paced action whilst not really 'limiting' itself to a specific set of sounds. What made Rush/Rush Adventure's music so special and so unique was how every sample used was taken from a variety of soundsets, with modern rock guitar samples being overlayed with hip-hop/trance drum beats and even orchestral clips being used once in a while. It really made for a diverse, experimental, but most importantly unique music style that I feel fits modern sonic's character the most. This was even apparent in CD, how it utilized a ton of hip-hop drum breaks and vocal shouts in combination with the old 90s synth patches.
    However, I don't think the kind of rock sound that was introduced in Adventure is necessarily unfitting, I just feel that the fact that you can easily classify it as "rock" makes it feel a bit too simplified for sonic the hedgehog. How 06 and a ton of other modern sonic games handled their music is that they simply used kind of 'rock-inspired' guitar licks and riffs with a variety of synths and instruments that aren't usually associated in a rock style.

    If I had to pick a second composer that I felt perfectly captured sonic throughout the years, it's Kenichi Tokoi. His work on colours was especially incredible, how he managed to mix up a diverse set of genres for each of the planets. It made a lot of sense that a lot of the songs were drastically different, but they still all had driving beats to give it that quick feel.

    Basically, I think the most important thing to keep in mind with sonic music is that:
    - It needs to be fast-paced (not necessarily just fast)
    - It needs to be diverse
    - It needs to fit the aesthetic
     
  5. Misinko

    Misinko Feel the the fire! Break your vision!

    • Messages: 41
    • Likes Received: 13
    I actually like a blend of styles for Classic Sonic. Thinking Sonic CD's style mixed with Sonic 3's. I don't particularly like the idea of either/or standing on their own. Both have become integral to the core of Sonic's identity, and both bring their own unique flavor to the games that can really diversity the soundtrack in a good way.

    I'd like to see Modern Sonic take a crack at Drum and Base, and Power Metal. Power Metal for themes, and Drum and Base for level music. Both fit the style of Modern very well, and multiple bands have even composed songs that would fit right at home in a Sonic game.
     
  6. Murasaki

    Murasaki Co-Creator of Sonic Utopia

    • Messages: 26
    • Likes Received: 43
    Hm... I rather think it depends on the themes of the game itself. Consider the various Mario games. Mario 64 was a step into a new dimension, and reflected this with its energetic, larger-than-life songs. Sunshine had a fun tropical feel, so the music was largely beach-ey and nautical. Galaxy's themes were epic and orchestral to reflect the mysterious space voyage. 3D World was simple and lighthearted to reflect its arcade-y feel.

    That said, while I don't mind a bit of rock here and there, I think the core foundation of the classics is mostly pop-related. Vaporwave reminds me a lot of classic Sonic games and their colorful, experimental a e s t h e t i c.
     
  7. InstantSonic

    InstantSonic Just add water!

    • Messages: 18
    • Likes Received: 10
    This, this, and this.
     
  8. Sonicg101

    Sonicg101 E Rank Member

    • Messages: 4
    • Likes Received: 0
    For Classic S3K, and for Modern, UNLEASHED.
     
  9. PFHedge

    PFHedge E Rank Member

    • Messages: 3
    • Likes Received: 1
    As far as I'm concerned, Sonic doesn't have one single 'perfect' style owing to different themes of the games (the darker themes of Sonic 06 versus the lighthearted feel of earlier Genesis games), however I would say certain musical characteristics need to be present. Specifically, the music needs pace to give the player that adrenal rush feel to compliment the speed of the game, whilst also using melodies to carry the songs. The lack of memorable melodies is why I think Sonic 4's score was a failure, for example. It had pace, but...not much else.
    I think the rock style of the modern games has suited quite well, as I don't think the chiptune-esque Genesis era music would work for it, but the same vice versa (genesis games with rock soundtracks don't work, but the chiptune stuff does work). That's why I think the characteristics of the music are more important than style.
    I'd also say generally the best Sonic themes feel upbeat (Green Hill, Sky Sanctuary, Metal Harbour, Planet Wisp) but that's more of a subjective thing I think.
     
  10. Ultrasun2000

    Ultrasun2000 Way past cool brainstormer.

    • Messages: 4
    • Likes Received: 1
    For favorite OST, I'm tied between Sonic CD US and Sonic Mania.
     
  11. Radical Dreamers

    Radical Dreamers E Rank Member

    • Messages: 3
    • Likes Received: 0
    Really depends what game it is. Classic games like Mania should stick with 90s House/Pop, since it's ideal with Sonic's rebellious and cool attitude. Tee Lopes nails Sonic music though.
     
  12. Prancer

    Prancer Going Nowhere

    • Messages: 27
    • Likes Received: 10
    I like the late 90s style, like Sonic Adventure 2
     
  13. EmeraldDebug

    EmeraldDebug E Rank Member

    • Messages: 7
    • Likes Received: 1
    I second OPs thoughts. But I'd like to add the sonic adventure 2 music also. And sonic lost worlds swing music. Why not the sonic advance series too.
     
  14. GuilhermeBMotta

    GuilhermeBMotta E Rank Member

    • Messages: 3
    • Likes Received: 14
    Certainly Jazz and Latin infused music. I think those are the pieces of music that marked me the most out of all the soundtracks for Classic Sonic, other than those I couldn't fit into a genre
     
Top